Choosing a new roof is a huge decision. You’re probably looking at your home and wondering what roofing material makes the most sense. The debate over a metal versus shingle roof often leaves homeowners feeling stuck between two very different options.
After all, you want to make the right call for your house and your wallet. Both residential roofing materials have advantages and disadvantages. This article will help you determine the best path for your specific situation in the metal versus shingle roof debate.
Metal roofing isn’t just for barns and industrial buildings anymore. It’s gaining popularity for homes due to its modern look and robust performance. However, it’s not the perfect solution for everyone. Different types are available, which influence the final look and price.
A common metal roof style is a standing seam metal roof known for its sleek, concealed fasteners. An alternative is the exposed fastener system, where the screw heads are visible on the metal panel. Both are durable options for protecting your home from severe weather.
People often choose metal for its incredible lifespan. A well-installed metal roof can last 50 years or even longer. You could install one and never think about replacing your roof again.
It also stands up to almost anything nature throws at it, especially extreme weather. A metal roof is great at handling strong winds, heavy rain, and snow. It’s also more fire-resistant, which adds a huge layer of security for your family.
Another big plus is energy efficiency, as the material choice can impact utility bills. Many metal roofs reflect sunlight, which can help lower your air conditioning bills during hot summers. According to the Department of Energy, this feature can significantly reduce your home’s cooling costs.
The biggest hurdle for most people is the up-front installation cost. Metal roofing generally costs more to buy and install than asphalt roofing. You’re paying for that long life right at the beginning.
Finding a roofing contractor with the right experience can also be tricky because a metal roof typically requires a specialized crew. A bad installation can lead to leaks and other major problems.
You might also hear about something called oil canning. This is a visual waviness that can appear on the flat parts of the panels. It doesn’t affect the roof’s performance, but some people don’t like how it looks.
Asphalt shingles are the most common roofing material in the U.S. for a reason. You probably see them on most homes in your neighborhood. They’re the traditional choice and have a long history of protecting homes.
The main reason shingle roofs are so popular is their affordability. It’s one of the most affordable roofing options you can choose. This makes this type of roof very attractive if you have a tight budget, offering a cost-effective solution up-front.
Installation is also faster and easier than with metal. Because so many homes have them, there are tons of roofing contractors who know how to install them. Finding someone for the job is rarely a problem, and the work can often be completed quickly.
Repairs are usually simple and less expensive. If a few shingles get damaged in a storm, a roofer can replace just the affected ones. This makes minor fixes pretty straightforward and keeps ongoing maintenance costs down.
The biggest trade-off for that low cost is a much shorter lifespan. A typical asphalt roof lasts about 15–25 years. You’ll likely have to replace it two or three times over the lifespan of a metal roof.
Shingles are much heavier than metal. This extra weight puts more stress on your home’s structure over time. Additionally, asphalt shingles tend to be more easily damaged by hail or high winds compared to metal.
Asphalt roofs also require more regular maintenance. They can be prone to moss or algae growth in humid climates, and shingles tend to lose their protective granules over time. These materials aren’t a great choice for the environment. While asphalt shingles can be recycled, the Environmental Protection Agency reports that millions of tons still end up in landfills each year.
Seeing the key differences right next to each other can help make your decision easier. Both materials offer protection, but they do it in very different ways. This table highlights what you can expect from each.
| Feature | Metal Roof | Shingle Roof |
|---|---|---|
| Average Lifespan | 50+ years | 15–25 years |
| Upfront Material Cost | High | Low |
| Long-Term Cost | Lower | Higher (due to replacements) |
| Durability | Excellent (wind, fire, hail) | Good (can be damaged) |
| Maintenance | Low | Low (may need minor repairs) |
| Energy Efficiency | High (reflects heat) | Low (absorbs heat) |
| Environmental Impact | Often recycled content, fully recyclable. | Contributes to landfill waste. |
Your choice really comes down to what you value most. There is no single correct answer for every homeowner. Think about these questions to help guide your decision.
If a lower initial cost is your top priority, shingles are the clear winner. But if you can make a smart investment now to save later, metal might be a better financial move in the long run.
If this is your forever home, a metal roof’s long lifespan makes a lot of sense. The impact on your home’s resale value is also worth considering, as a durable metal roof can be a selling point in the real estate market.
If you live in an area with a high risk of wildfires, hurricanes, or heavy hail, a metal roof offers superior protection. For milder climates, shingles often provide more than enough defense against the elements.
When it comes down to choosing between a metal roof and shingles, it really depends on what works best for you. Asphalt shingle roofs are a solid, budget-friendly choice that’ll keep your home protected for years. Metal roofs, on the other hand, are more of a long-term investment, and they’re super durable and can even help you save on energy bills.
That said, metal roofs usually cost more up-front, but their long lifespan can make them more affordable in the long run. Shingles are great if you’re working with a tighter budget and want something reliable.
At the end of the day, both options are great, but it just comes down to your priorities. Think about your budget, long-term plans, and what your home really needs. Picking the right roof will give you peace of mind for years, and that’s what really matters.
1727 Clearwood Dr, Longview, TX 75604
Mon - Sat: 7am - 8pm
Sun Closed
Call us for a free estimate
903-790-1964